July 6, 2025 Your Source for Brentwood News

Letter to Editor: Confronting Racism in Housing

“We shouldn’t feel guilty if we proceed with this program,” Mr. Hall wrote at the end of his 22 Point Plan to deal with homelessness. “We should feel guilty if we don’t.”

I am sure Mr. Hall is a well-intentioned person, as are the people who read this newspaper. But I think his proposal misses the mark by a few miles, and I don’t feel any guilt saying so.

There are three elements of Mr. Hall’s proposal with which I disagree. The first is the core of his proposal — his suggestion that we should remove the unhoused to a newly constructed facility somewhere on the outskirts of Los Angeles. I cannot support any program where the premise is to force people into a facility against their will.

I assume the appeal of this encampment idea is it looks and sounds like a utilitarian way to provide the greatest number of people with certain sanitary needs, but my concern is this path will lead to organized cruelty. If history is any guide, an institutionalization plan like this would put us on a slippery slope to repeating the mistakes of the past, like Manzanar or Willowbrook, that degraded people’s humanity, robbing them of their dignity. 

I also disagree with Mr. Hall’s belief that Judge Carter, or any judicial officer, would think this proposal has the imprimatur of legal validity. Judge Carter is a federal judge overseeing a massive lawsuit involving the city and county’s responses to homelessness. But in Hall’s proposal, Judge Carter would potentially play a starring role as the “czar” overseeing this facility.

Carter would take away people’s right to privacy and personal property, supervise the psychological profiling and deprogramming of people with complex health needs, and green light the police to coerce people into these facilities. I think Judge Carter would agree each of these ideas is an affront to the Constitution and prime examples of cutting a great road through the law to get after the Devil.

Finally, Mr. Hall’s proposal omits important aspects of what Judge Carter has actually said about this issue. The first third of Carter’s 110-page injunction is devoted to an analysis of what he sees as the root cause of houselessness: structural racism. The phrase he uses is “organized abandonment in housing,” where intentional and deliberate public policy decisions created barriers to housing.

As Carter points out, this has produced our present situation where 42% of unhoused people in Los Angeles are Black, even though they make up just 8% of the population. Mr. Hall’s proposal does not acknowledge the racial disparities among the unhoused population and thus would not do anything to address the root causes of inequality and scarcity of housing in California. 

I would encourage anyone who has read Mr. Hall’s proposal to read Judge Carter’s injunction also. It is an urgent document that asks us to be more aware of and sensitive to the racial dimension of the issue of houselessness. I understand that some people feel a sense of urgency to address the issue of houselessness now. But if we do not listen to what Judge Carter has written for us, and if we refuse to confront structural racism in housing, then we will only continue down the same path.

Moreover, if we choose to ignore Judge Carter’s analysis and continue to talk about poverty as an issue of personal failing or even mental illness, then we are only giving ourselves the false impression that the solutions we need are easy, obvious, and do not require conversations about inequality that might make some of us feel uncomfortable.

Philip Portnoy

Related Posts

Michael Madsen, Star of Reservoir Dogs and Kill Bill, Dies at 67 in Malibu

July 4, 2025

July 4, 2025

Actor Remembered for His Intense Performances and as a Poet  Actor Michael Madsen, known for his distinctive gravelly voice and...

Pentagon Orders Troop Drawdown in LA: 150 National Guard Members Reassigned to Wildfire Duty

July 1, 2025

July 1, 2025

Federal Forces Begin Partial Withdrawal From Protest Response as California Leaders Push Back U.S. Northern Command announced Tuesday that 150...

The Westside Lights Up for July 4: Fireworks, Drone Shows, and Parades Return Across West Los Angeles

June 30, 2025

June 30, 2025

From Marina Del Rey’s Fireworks to Culver City’s 1980s-Themed Drone Show, Get Ready to Celebrate From fireworks over Marina del...

City Issues Determination That Could Clear Way for Barry Building Demolition

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

Preservation Deemed Infeasible Due to Economic and Social Factors The historic Barry Building on San Vicente Boulevard may soon face...

Historic Sawtelle Nursery Site Could Become 40-Unit Townhome Complex

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

Sawtelle Continues to Change as Nursery Site Faces Redevelopment Plans have been submitted to redevelop a nursery site, F.K. Nursery,...

Drake Slashes Price on Beverly Hills Estate to $79 Million Amid Market Slowdown

June 29, 2025

June 29, 2025

Price Cut Adds to a Broader Retreat From His Los Angeles Real Estate Holdings. Musician Drake has reduced the price...

Brentwood Gardener Brutally Attacked by Squatter; Neighbors Demand Action

June 27, 2025

June 27, 2025

Rodolfo Roman Was Hospitalized After Being Beaten With a Metal Pole Tensions are rising in a Brentwood neighborhood after a...

Brentwood Home by Landry Design Group Wins Top National Architecture Award

June 24, 2025

June 24, 2025

Landry Design Group Wins Gold Nugget Awards for Brentwood, Crestwood Projects Landry Design Group (LDG) earned two top honors at...

Squatter-Plagued Beverly Grove Buildings Could Be Razed After Hazard Cleanup

June 24, 2025

June 24, 2025

Demolition of Three Abandoned Apartments May Begin in Two Weeks Three abandoned apartment buildings in Beverly Grove may soon be...

Recent Homebuyer Down Payments Slip for First Time in Nearly Two Years

June 23, 2025

June 23, 2025

April’s Median Down Payment Fell as Buyers Lean Toward Lower-Cost Homes The median down payment made by U.S. homebuyers dropped...

Del Rey Affordable Housing Project to Rise on Former Charter School Site

June 23, 2025

June 23, 2025

Community Corp., Local Faith Group Team Up to Build 122 New Apartments Plans are moving forward for a new residential...

Paris Hilton Buys Mark Wahlberg’s Beverly Park Mansion for $63.1M

June 22, 2025

June 22, 2025

The Heiress and Media Mogul Joins a Star-Studded Neighborhood Paris Hilton and husband Carter Reum have purchased a high-profile estate...

Journalist Files Lawsuit After Being Hit by ‘Less Lethal’ Munition Fired by Sheriff’s Deputies

June 17, 2025

June 17, 2025

LASD Faces Legal Claim After Journalist Wounded at Anti-Ice Rally  Independent photojournalist Nick Stern has filed a civil rights claim...

US Marines Temporarily Detain Civilian Near Federal Building in West Los Angeles

June 16, 2025

June 16, 2025

Military Confirms First Known Detention by Active-Duty Troops Deployed by Trump U.S. Marines temporarily detained a civilian near the Wilshire...

Americans Split on Immigration and Tariffs’ Impact on Housing Affordability, Survey Shows

June 15, 2025

June 15, 2025

Survey Finds Over Half Believe Less Immigration Could Drive Up Home Prices  A new Redfin-commissioned survey reveals that U.S. homeowners...