November 30, 2022 Your Source for Brentwood News

Brentwood Beat: From Here to Where?

There has been much political theater at the national level in recent weeks, with Governors Ron DeSantis and Greg Abbott sending immigrants who cross over from Mexico to Martha’s Vineyard and Democratically run cities like New York and Chicago. 

The Republicans are making a statement about the lack of border control and Democrats are saying the Republicans are cruel for using the immigrants as pawns in today’s partisan conflicts. 

Governor Gavin Newsom made some snarky remarks about DeSantis, and DeSantis said all that hair gel was affecting Governor Newsom’s judgment.

I’m not sure how any of this actually solves our country’s long-overdue need to come up with an immigration policy that makes sense, but we live in an entertainment age, when political stunts and a snarky soundbite substitute for smart policy. 

I think we see this at the local level, as well. Everyone knows we have a homelessness crisis, but nobody seems to be able to do anything about it. Westside moderates and conservatives say we need more tough love; liberals and ultraliberals say we need more compassion. 

But leaving people on the street year after year isn’t compassionate. Tons of money gets spent on this each year, but the problem keeps growing. Because of our great weather and socially tolerant politics, many homeless from other states come to California. 

We shuffle encampments from one location to another and hope people will see it as “progress” when an encampment disappears. But once the problem has been moved from our backyard to someone else’s backyard – as happened in Brentwood this year when the encampment along the VA was removed – we tend to forget about the issue. But how many of these people really landed well?

It is not unreasonable for those who feel put upon to want to move the problem elsewhere. Just as residents of Texas, Florida and Arizona want to ship the immigrants off to Chicago, New York, Sacramento or Martha’s Vineyard, the residents of Venice Beach no longer want to be the dumping ground for the region’s – and even the country’s – homeless population. 

Just as those in Texas, Arizona and Florida want the rest of the country to share in the burden of absorbing immigrants, I foresee the day when residents of Venice Beach will demand that the homeless population be spread around to other parts of the Westside, including Brentwood. 

Brentwood has clout and has a way of protecting itself, but is that fair to Santa Monica, Venice Beach, Del Rey and other areas that absorb more than their fair share of the homeless?

What’s really needed is a big, FEMA-like approach to all this: We need much more temporary shelter — and quickly; we need much more in the way of mental health services – also quickly; and we need much more streamlining of services (and accountability for results) from the agencies that are supposed to be handling all this. We need to federalize our response to both homelessness and immigration; it’s not right certain communities and states bear more than their fair share of the burden. 

There is no way we can afford or build enough permanent supportive housing fast enough to deal with the crisis at hand; we need a strategy to get from here to there. We need temporary shelters like tiny homes and underutilized retail and office buildings. Shared housing can be a big part of the answer. 

But in California – and LA especially – lack of land is a real issue. We need to shift the conversation from “not here,” or “let’s build tiny homes” — to “where, exactly?” 

Where, exactly, are we going to put these new, temporary shelters? Where will the tiny homes go? Which buildings can be converted to housing? Which landlords are willing to take in the homeless? 

At some point – quickly, I hope – we need to get from the general to the really, really specific. Otherwise, this problem will never get solved. We are fiddling while Rome burns.

in Opinion
Related Posts

Brentwood Beat: Rick Caruso for Homelessness Czar

November 23, 2022

November 23, 2022

We have a new mayor, Karen Bass, and a new CD11 city council member, Traci Park.  Congratulations all around! The...

Column: Erin Darling Concedes Race to Traci Park to Succeed Mike Bonin in LA’s CD-11

November 22, 2022

November 22, 2022

The close contest between two Venetians ends with Park garnering 53% of the vote to Darling’s 47% By Nick Antonicello...

Column – Gas Gougers Beware: California Is Onto You at Last

November 11, 2022

November 11, 2022

By Tom Elias It has taken more than 50 years of on-and-off gasoline price gouging, but at long last California...

$87,581,047.01: Candidate Rick Caruso on Pace to Smash All Spending Records in His Bid to Become Mayor of Los Angeles

November 4, 2022

November 4, 2022

Caruso overwhelming Bass nearly 10-1! By Nick Antonicello According to the LA Ethics Commission as of October 31st, billionaire developer...

“Ten Takes” to Watch as CD-11 Hopefuls Park & Darling Close out the Campaign in a Mad Dash to the Finish Line!

November 4, 2022

November 4, 2022

By Nick Antonicello And after some sixteen months of posturing, positioning and intensive campaigning be it door to door, shaking...

Dirty Campaigning: Not Welcome in CD11

November 1, 2022

November 1, 2022

I know I said a while back I wouldn’t comment on the Traci Park/Erin Darling race. But once again, we’ve...

Column: Who’s the ‘True’ Democrat in CD-11?

October 30, 2022

October 30, 2022

So who is the true Democrat in this race to succeed Mike Bonin in CD-11? While the campaign for city...

Column: Tenant Support Could Tip the Political Scales in CD-11 Council Race

October 29, 2022

October 29, 2022

Darling pushes advocacy of renter’s rights over Park in tightly contested battle to succeed Mike Bonin! By Nick Antonicello In...

Column: Money & Messaging That Is Persuasive and Memorable May Just Make Rick Caruso Our Next Mayor!

October 25, 2022

October 25, 2022

Moving away from direct mail, Caruso saturates broadcast television with a more disciplined message that is resonating with an angry...

Column: Excess School Lands for Teacher Housing?

October 22, 2022

October 22, 2022

By Tom Elias, Columnist Do voters want more teachers living in their communities, even if it means a little more...

Column: What Next for LA?

October 18, 2022

October 18, 2022

By Nick Antonicello The ongoing racism scandal that has engulfed and swallowed city government whole could be an opportunity in...

Column: Racist Remarks Have No Place in Politics or Government

October 14, 2022

October 14, 2022

The ugly side of our discourse rears its head once again! By Nick Antonicello Some thirty years ago Rodney King...

Column: Candidates Darling & Park Move to the Center in CD-11 on the Issue of Homelessness

October 13, 2022

October 13, 2022

Recent mailings suggest a consensus, common sense approach as campaign intensifies in closing weeks! By Nick Antonicello While campaigns have...

Column: The Sixty Million Dollar Man!

October 3, 2022

October 3, 2022

Caruso’s crushing ad buy obliterates all spending records by one candidate for the office of Mayor of LA By Nick...

Column: The Endorsement Sham Belittles a Productive Dialogue in the Race for LA County Sheriff!

September 30, 2022

September 30, 2022

LA Times endorsement of Robert Luna is a farce, bordering on the political absurd! By Nick Antonicello Endorsements by newspapers...