March 29, 2023 Your Source for Brentwood News

Column: State Usurping Key Powers From Cities

By Tom Elias

All over California last fall, hundreds of the civic minded spent thousands of hours and millions of dollars running for posts on city councils and county boards.

Some of them may now be wondering why they bothered. For over the last three years, state government has gradually usurped almost full jurisdiction over one of the key powers always previously held by locally elected officials: The ability to decide what their city or county will look like and feel like over the next few decades.

That’s done via land use decisions which control how many housing units and commercial sites can be built up in a given time.

Via a series of laws mandating new levels of density everywhere in the state, whether or not they are needed and justified, this key local power now belongs to largely anonymous state officials who know little or nothing about most places whose future they are deciding.

It’s being done through the elimination of single-family, or R-1, zoning. It’s being done via the new requirement that the state Department of Housing and Community Development approve housing elements for every locality. If HCD does not approve such a plan for a city, developers can target it with virtually no limits, if they choose.

It’s all based on a supposed need for at least 1.8 million new housing units touted by HCD. This, despite the fact that the state auditor last spring found that HCD did not properly vet the documents and other instruments on which that estimate was based.

What’s more, only three years earlier, HCD was claiming more than 3.5 million new units were needed. Less than one-eighth that many have risen, yet HCD has cut its need estimate considerably.

And yet… cities and counties must do what they’re told by this demonstrably incompetent agency, or risk lawsuits and big losses in state grants for everything from sewers and road maintenance to police and fire departments. State Attorney General Rob Bonta even set up a new unit in his Justice Department to threaten and pursue noncompliant cities.

This leads localities to approve developments in ways they never did before, including some administrative approvals without so much as the possibility of a public hearing.

It leads to the absurd, as with Atherton trying to get state approval of a plan forcing almost all local homeowners to create “additional dwelling units” on the one-acre lots long required in the city. That’s instead of building almost 400 townhouses or apartments in a town of barely 7,000 persons.

And in Santa Monica, because the city council did not get its housing element approved, developers can probably not be stopped as they make plans for at least 12 large new buildings. So much for bucolic seaside living.

Santa Monica is also an example of a city buckling to state pressure to allow huge projects opposed by most of its citizens, a majority of whom are renters. That city has done nothing to stop or alter the largest development in its history, to be built on a property at a major intersection now occupied by a grocery and several other stores.

Despite heavy community interest, evidenced by the more than 2,000 persons on a Zoom call about the project last winter, the city will hold no public hearings and does not respond to most written communications from its citizens about the development. All because it fears the state will sue if it objects.

Several cities have begun to fight parts of today’s state domination of land use. Four Los Angeles County cities – Redondo Beach, Torrance, Carson and Whittier – are seeking a court order negating the 2021 Senate Bill 9, which allows single family homes to be replaced by as many as six units, with cities unable to nix any such project.

As city councils and county boards see their constituents objecting loudly to much of this scene, it’s inevitable that other lawsuits will follow. No one can predict whether or not courts will find the state Legislature and Gov. Gavin Newsom have vastly overreached in their power grab, which is all for the sake of increased density and based on unfounded predictions by bureaucrats who answer to no one.

Related Posts

Office Building Sales Plummet by 76% in Los Angeles

March 27, 2023

March 27, 2023

Transfer tax and low interest rates contributing to decline in L.A. office sales By Dolores Quintana In the city of...

Luxury Brentwood Chateau-Style Estate Owned by Handbag Designer Tyler Ellis Listed for $42 Million

March 26, 2023

March 26, 2023

Ellis is selling her stunning 6-bedroom, 10-bath French-inspired mansion in Brentwood, LA, for nearly $30 million more than what she...

L.A.’s $100 Million Megamansions Are Getting Mega Price Cuts

March 19, 2023

March 19, 2023

Properties see price cuts ahead of Measure ULA taking effect By Dolores Quintana Bel Air is home to this modern...

Mohamed Hadid Ordered to Pay $2.3M in Legal Fees for Tearing Down Mega-Mansion Illegally

March 19, 2023

March 19, 2023

Despite facing criminal charges and probation, Hadid continued with the construction that ended in a civil suit, resulting in the...

Column: SB 9 Ended R-1 Zoning, but It’s Not Meeting Goals

March 11, 2023

March 11, 2023

By Tom Elias More than a year after it took effect, the landmark housing density law known as SB 9...

Sprawling Bel Air Megamansion Returns to Market With $59M Price Tag

March 11, 2023

March 11, 2023

Built in 2020, the more than 41,000-square-foot estate is among the largest “amenity-driven, ultra-luxury property on the market” The Somma...

Formula One Heiress Petra Ecclestone Buys New $30.5M Estate in Brentwood

March 10, 2023

March 10, 2023

Petra Ecclestone and husband spend $30.5 million for a 13,000-square-foot Rockingham Road estate  By Dolores Quintana Formula One heiress Petra...

Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles Takes Legal Action Against LA’s New Renter Protection Regulations

March 10, 2023

March 10, 2023

The AAGLA’s lawsuit seeks to overturn Ordinance No. 1877764 and Ordinance No. 187763 The Apartment Association of Greater Los Angeles...

Zoltan Pali’s Architectural Triumph in Bel-Air Listed for $14 Million

March 5, 2023

March 5, 2023

The contemporary oasis boasts mesmerizing views and luxurious amenities By Dolores Quintana Zoltan Pali, of the architectural firm SPF: a...

Tides Equities Co-Founder, Sean Kia, Buys $14.5 Million Brentwood Home as Investment

March 5, 2023

March 5, 2023

The Real Deal reports that the 9,700 sq ft estate will be renovated and sold in the next 9-12 months...

Actress Thandiwe Newton Sells Rustic Topanga Home for Profit in Just Four Months

February 26, 2023

February 26, 2023

“Westworld” star makes $125,000 on recent sale By Dolores Quintana After only four months, actress Thandiwe Newton has sold her...

Column: The Inevitable Conversions Begin Multiplying

February 25, 2023

February 25, 2023

By Tom Elias It’s a phenomenon from New York to Dallas to Fresno and Los Angeles, one that seemed inevitable...

Permanent Supportive Housing Complex Debuts in West Los Angeles

February 25, 2023

February 25, 2023

51-unit now open at 11010 Santa Monica Boulevard In a ceremony held recently, the Weingart Center and local officials celebrated...

Brentwood Beat – Westside Urban Forum: Small Can Be Good

February 24, 2023

February 24, 2023

I was invited by fellow Brentwood resident Josh Stephens to moderate a recent panel conversation conducted by the Westside Urban...

Column: The Fantasy World of California Housing Policy

February 20, 2023

February 20, 2023

By Tom Elias If you’re looking for sure things among bills under consideration in the state Legislature, think of one...