September 24, 2023 Your Source for Brentwood News

Column: State Usurping Key Powers From Cities

By Tom Elias

All over California last fall, hundreds of the civic minded spent thousands of hours and millions of dollars running for posts on city councils and county boards.

Some of them may now be wondering why they bothered. For over the last three years, state government has gradually usurped almost full jurisdiction over one of the key powers always previously held by locally elected officials: The ability to decide what their city or county will look like and feel like over the next few decades.

That’s done via land use decisions which control how many housing units and commercial sites can be built up in a given time.

Via a series of laws mandating new levels of density everywhere in the state, whether or not they are needed and justified, this key local power now belongs to largely anonymous state officials who know little or nothing about most places whose future they are deciding.

It’s being done through the elimination of single-family, or R-1, zoning. It’s being done via the new requirement that the state Department of Housing and Community Development approve housing elements for every locality. If HCD does not approve such a plan for a city, developers can target it with virtually no limits, if they choose.

It’s all based on a supposed need for at least 1.8 million new housing units touted by HCD. This, despite the fact that the state auditor last spring found that HCD did not properly vet the documents and other instruments on which that estimate was based.

What’s more, only three years earlier, HCD was claiming more than 3.5 million new units were needed. Less than one-eighth that many have risen, yet HCD has cut its need estimate considerably.

And yet… cities and counties must do what they’re told by this demonstrably incompetent agency, or risk lawsuits and big losses in state grants for everything from sewers and road maintenance to police and fire departments. State Attorney General Rob Bonta even set up a new unit in his Justice Department to threaten and pursue noncompliant cities.

This leads localities to approve developments in ways they never did before, including some administrative approvals without so much as the possibility of a public hearing.

It leads to the absurd, as with Atherton trying to get state approval of a plan forcing almost all local homeowners to create “additional dwelling units” on the one-acre lots long required in the city. That’s instead of building almost 400 townhouses or apartments in a town of barely 7,000 persons.

And in Santa Monica, because the city council did not get its housing element approved, developers can probably not be stopped as they make plans for at least 12 large new buildings. So much for bucolic seaside living.

Santa Monica is also an example of a city buckling to state pressure to allow huge projects opposed by most of its citizens, a majority of whom are renters. That city has done nothing to stop or alter the largest development in its history, to be built on a property at a major intersection now occupied by a grocery and several other stores.

Despite heavy community interest, evidenced by the more than 2,000 persons on a Zoom call about the project last winter, the city will hold no public hearings and does not respond to most written communications from its citizens about the development. All because it fears the state will sue if it objects.

Several cities have begun to fight parts of today’s state domination of land use. Four Los Angeles County cities – Redondo Beach, Torrance, Carson and Whittier – are seeking a court order negating the 2021 Senate Bill 9, which allows single family homes to be replaced by as many as six units, with cities unable to nix any such project.

As city councils and county boards see their constituents objecting loudly to much of this scene, it’s inevitable that other lawsuits will follow. No one can predict whether or not courts will find the state Legislature and Gov. Gavin Newsom have vastly overreached in their power grab, which is all for the sake of increased density and based on unfounded predictions by bureaucrats who answer to no one.

Related Posts

Sought-After Brentwood Glen Gem: Traditional Home with Versatile Layout Hits Market

September 18, 2023

September 18, 2023

Clean and Bright 3-Bedroom Residence in Coveted Brentwood Neighborhood  By Dolores Quintana Ensconced in the highly-coveted Brentwood Glen, this delightful...

Los Angeles City Council Considers Zoning Changes to Accelerate Affordable Housing Development

September 18, 2023

September 18, 2023

City Council Motion Seeks to Remove Density Restrictions on Public Facilities Zones By Dolores Quintana  The City of Los Angeles...

California Renters Get Some Relief as Apartment Prices Again Drop in August

September 18, 2023

September 18, 2023

Landlords Forced To Offer Discounts as Rental Units Stay Empty By Dolores Quintana In August, the average monthly cost of...

Federal Challenge to Measure ULA Dismissed: Los Angeles Superior Court Now the Only Arena For ULA Legal Challenge

September 11, 2023

September 11, 2023

Judge Redirects Controversial Dispute, Leaving Fate of ULA in the Hands of Local Courts By Dolores Quintana On September 5th,...

Los Angeles General Plan Land Use Element Draft Updates Released

September 10, 2023

September 10, 2023

CD 11 Councilmember Will Hold Listening Session For Residents  By Dolores Quintana The General Plan Land Use Element of Los...

Battle Over Marilyn Monroe’s Historic Last Home: Demolition Plans Stalled

September 10, 2023

September 10, 2023

CD 11 Councilmember Traci Park Steps In To Halt the Demolition  By Dolores Quintana The Los Angeles City Council has...

Palisadian Tenants Spar With New Building Management

September 6, 2023

September 6, 2023

Management Workers Were Ordered to Remove the Complex’s Washing Machine By Zach Armstrong After tenants of a Pacific Palisades complex...

City of Los Angeles Approves First $150 Million In Expenditures From Measure ULA Tax

September 5, 2023

September 5, 2023

Funds Allocated from ‘Mansion Tax’ to Assist Vulnerable Communities By Dolores Quintana Los Angeles has initiated the utilization of funds...

Debate Heats Up as LA’s Rent Freeze Nears End Date in February 2024

August 27, 2023

August 27, 2023

Real Estate Experts and Landlords Push for Earlier Conclusion By Dolores Quintana Even though the city of Los Angeles is...

Judge Shuffle Continues in LA’s High-Stakes Measure ULA Tax Legal Battle

August 27, 2023

August 27, 2023

Third Attempt to Secure Impartial Judge as Legal Challenge Heats Up By Dolores Quintana The Los Angeles Superior Court is...

LAHSA Announced Rapid Response to Tropical Storm Hilary Starting On August 17

August 20, 2023

August 20, 2023

Collaborative Efforts, Shelters Provide Safety Amidst Adverse Weather By Dolores Quintana The Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority (LAHSA) has been...

A Brentwood Gem: Celebrity Estate with Serene Two-Acre Sanctuary Hits the Market

August 20, 2023

August 20, 2023

After Nearly 30 Years, This Tranquil Oasis Offers Timeless Elegance and Luxury Living By Dolores Quintana Nestled on a sprawling...

Los Angeles City Council Votes To Approve Motion To Call Halt To Bulgari Hotel Approval Process

August 16, 2023

August 16, 2023

Proposed Hotel Would Be Built In Benedict Canyon, CD5 Yaroslavky Authored Motion  By Dolores Quintana The Los Angeles City Council...

California’s Dichotomy: Rising Numbers of Ultra-Rich Residents Amidst Deepening Inequality

August 13, 2023

August 13, 2023

Amidst Tales of Population Decreasing, Number of Millionaires and Billionaires Rise By Dolores Quintana Amidst population shifts, exorbitant housing costs,...

Domino’s Executive Lists Luxurious Bel-Air Mansion for $29.95 Million

August 13, 2023

August 13, 2023

Eight-Bedroom Residence Overlooks Stone Canyon Reservoir  By Dolores Quintana Donald Meij, a key figure at Domino’s Pizza Enterprises, has entered...