Despite Safety Concerns, the Commission Upheld the Building’s Protected Status
According to the South Brentwood Resident’s Association Newsletter, The Los Angeles Cultural Heritage Commission recommended certifying the Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the former Dutton’s Books building but opposed its demolition after the last meeting held on September 5. The vacant building at 11973 San Vicente Boulevard is the issue and the owner wants to demolish the building but would have to get a waiver because the building has historically protected status.
The commission recommended that the Department of Building and Safety certify the EIR for the site. However, they did not support adopting a Statement of Overriding Considerations, a step that would allow the demolition of the building despite any adverse environmental impacts.
At the hearing, members of the South Brentwood Residents Association and other community residents supported demolition, arguing the structure is neither seismically sound nor ADA compliant. Engineering assessments presented by the owner indicated that retrofitting the building’s soft-story design would exceed its value.
Councilwoman Traci Park, who supports the demolition, was represented at the meeting. Her office stated that Park had secured an agreement with the owner to retain key architectural elements in any new construction on the site.
Despite these arguments, the commission upheld the building’s protected status, citing its historic value. As a result, the former Dutton’s Books building, which some residents view as an eyesore, will remain for the time being.
The SBRA newsletter urges supporters of demolition to contact Councilmember Traci Park and city officials to request that the Department of Building and Safety certify the EIR, adopt a Statement of Overriding Considerations, and issue the necessary demolition permit.
